GAB is pleased to welcome this post by Mark Worth, executive director of the European Center for Whistleblower Rights in Berlin. Mark has been a whistleblower caseworker, investigative journalist, legal advisor, policy advocate, and is now Director of Project “Blowback.” The project is the first-ever investigation into the chronic failings of whistleblower protection systems across Europe. This post is a snapshot. The full investigation is scheduled to be published in spring 2027.
When Bitten Jensen discovered that elderly and disabled people in Denmark weren’t receiving their public benefits, she did what any decent person would do: she got involved. She told her boss at the municipality office in Frederiksberg about the problem. When that got her nowhere, she called a government minister. When that didn’t work, she went to the media.
Thanks to 89 case files provided by Jensen, the Danish newspaper Information exposed how vulnerable citizens were being deprived of their monthly payments. The publicity helped fix the problem. But rather than thanking and perhaps promoting her, a staffer at Frederiksberg’s employment office filed a criminal complaint against her. Jensen was fired, prosecuted and convicted of disclosing confidential information and abusing her position.
In the first such case of its kind in Europe, Denmark’s Supreme Court upheld Jensen’s conviction and 5,000 kroner fine (US$770). To her shock, she lost the case even though judges acknowledged she acted “in good faith” and her report had a “factual basis.” Her disclosure, judges continued, served the “legitimate public interest” and “contributed to a growing public debate” that led to legislative reforms.
Despite this lavish praise, and even though Jensen’s superiors ignored her, the court said it was not “necessary” for her to report the problems to the media. Moreover, the court overlooked a provision in Denmark’s whistleblower protection law that permits such disclosures, while granting whistleblowers immunity from prosecution. A short time later, another public official in Denmark filed a criminal complaint against another whistleblower. When he tried to explain to the police that he is protected, they responded, “We are charging you anyway.”
This is happening in Denmark, a famously “clean” country that has held the #1 spot on the World Justice Project’s Rule of Law Index for the past 15 years.
Bitten Jensen’s defeat has become a poster child for the failings of a 2019 European Union law that was supposed to shield whistleblowers from harm. When Directive 2019/1937 was passed, then-European Justice Commissioner Věra Jourová called it a “game-changer” for “honest people” who report crime and corruption. However, the law almost certainly has produced more victims than had the law not been passed in the first place.
Whistleblower offices across Europe coax well-meaning people into coming forward with evidence of misconduct. “As a whistleblower, you are protected against reprisals,” says Denmark’s National Whistleblower Scheme. Only after they are fired, sued, investigated or prosecuted – or sometimes all of these punishments in concert – do whistleblowers realize there are no mechanisms to get their job back or avoid being dragged into court.
Though ostensibly compliant with the EU Directive, the whistleblower laws in nearly every EU country lack even the most basic tools to protect whistleblowers. Firings and court actions targeting whistleblowers continue unabatedly, even as whistleblower offices in every EU country pledge protections.
Since the Directive took effect in 2021, more than 10,000 people have sent reports to whistleblower offices in EU countries. Yet only a few dozen people have been protected from retaliation. A vast majority of these offices wrongly tell citizens they will be protected if they report corruption. In reality, only 2 of 27 EU countries – Ireland and Slovakia – have an office with the legal authority to order a whistleblower to be protected or compensated.
On November 9, a judge in Croatia ruled against a doctor who exposed bribery in the pharmaceutical industry. The judge said she doesn’t have to comply with the EU Directive, nor does she have to consider the national Ombudsman’s conclusion that the whistleblower was illegally retaliated against. The judge then ordered the whistleblower to pay €84,000 in legal fees to the opposing attorneys, who work for the medical technology multinational Johnson & Johnson.
Despite having 35 staffers and a €6 million annual budget, the Netherlands’ Whistleblowers Authority has protected no whistleblowers since it was founded 10 years ago. The agency says whistleblower retaliation is banned in the Netherlands, yet it has no authority to protect, reinstate or compensate corruption witnesses. Rather, many victimized whistleblowers have been ensnared in years-long legal battles against high-powered attorneys.
Luxembourg’s Office for Whistleblowers says whistleblowers have “a legal shield against retaliation.” Yet, the office only answers questions. It does not receive or investigate whistleblower reports or retaliation complaints – much less does it protect whistleblowers from retaliation or compensate them for damages.
Right now, the European Commission is conducting a formal review of the EU Directive. So far, officials in Brussels have not responded to concerns from whistleblower advocates that the current system is failing. Like the disclosures from whistleblowers themselves, the warnings from advocates also are falling on deaf ears.
This article, a part of project “Blowback,” was developed with the support of Journalismfund Europe.
